Prosecutors absolutely oppose Brooklynn Chandler Willy’s request to withdraw her guilty plea in the Ferrum Capital fraud case – calling it not “fair and just” to the “numerous vulnerable elderly victims” who believed her December sentencing would provide some closure for the millions of dollars they lost.

Willy now claims she was not given enough time to consider the plea deal, plus her former attorney did not explain it well before she pleaded guilty in March 10 to counts including wire fraud and conspiracy related to the Lubbock-based company.

Joseph Blackwell, assistant U.S. attorney, countered her claim in a Friday filing, saying he met “at length” with Willy and her husband to discuss the plea deal and she had 22 days to decide. Blackwell also pointed out Willy has a law degree, even if she never practiced.

Willy also claimed she did not knowingly defraud anyone, to which Blackwell quoted Willy saying back in March saying she was a crook.

Willy – Ferrum’s San Antonio affiliate – was set to be sentenced four days after the Dec. 10 sentencing for Lubbock’s Joshua Allen and Michael Cox, Ferrum’s co-founders.

Willy asked San Antonio judge Fred Biery on November 5 to step away from the case, which he did – reassigning it to Xavier Rodriguez, who set a Dec. 15 hearing to consider Willy’s desire to take back her guilty plea.

Biery and Rodriguez both ordered the U.S. Attorney’s office to file a written response ahead of the hearing.

That’s what Blackwell filed Friday, writing, “Willy victimized many. Most are elderly. Many have serious health concerns. Some have already died. If she is permitted to withdraw, many victims who have testified once before would need to testify again. Not all will be able. Restitution would be delayed and Willy would continue to dissipate assets.”

Blackwell emphasized many times Willy is not claiming innocence – she admits the crimes in her plea deal. She just does not want to be held responsible for the same amount of money prosecutors blame her for, Blackwell claimed.

Willy claimed she’s being held responsible for more than she agreed to in her plea deal, which Lubbock Report covered here.

If Willy were to get the statutory maximum on all counts, she would be sentenced to more than 170 years. Realistically, it will be much less. Willy’s attorney wrote the sentence is on track to be 17 and two-thirds years or more based on federal sentencing guidelines.

Background:

Joshua Allen and Michael Cox, both from Lubbock, started Ferrum Capital in 2017 with Ferrum II, Ferrum III and Ferrum IV following later.

Ferrum raised money for Collins Asset Group – an Austin-based debt collection company. Prosecutors called it a Ponzi scheme – meaning new investors raised money to pay back previous investors and the business model was never going to be profitable.

“The total scheme involved more than 500 victims and approximately $60 million,” Blackwell wrote.

A 2025 indictment against Allen, Cox and Willy claimed more than $67 million and the dollar figures have varied across various legal proceedings including lawsuits and bankruptcy cases.

Collins defaulted to Ferrum in 2023, according to court records and a state court put Ferrum under the control of a receiver, John Patrick Lowe, in 2024.

Willy, who acted as the San Antonio-based affiliate of Ferrum, accepted a plea deal in March, and a federal jury in San Antonio convicted Allen and Cox in August.

Click here to see our ongoing Ferrum Capital coverage.

Not claiming innocence

Blackwell pointed out Willy does not claim innocence.

“A criminal defendant does not have an absolute right to withdraw a guilty plea,” Blackwell wrote.

“A defendant must not only assert her innocence but also provide a ‘substantial supporting record’ for that assertion. … Willy has failed to provide any record of innocence,” Blackwell explained – and cited case law to back up his argument.

Willy claimed she did not realize she would be held responsible for more than just the victims explicitly referenced in her plea agreement.

But that’s not a claim of innocence, Blackwell argued. That’s just Willy disagreeing with prosecutors on how much is her responsibility.

On September 30, the office of U.S. Attorney provided a preliminary loss estimate of $18.56 million connected to Willy. Of that amount, $12.2 million is attributed to Ferrum Capital investors. Willy was expecting none of it to be from Ferrum Capital.

Willy affirmed under penalty of perjury for her November 5 request, “When I placed clients in Ferrum Capital notes, I did not know that Mr. Allen and Mr. Cox were defrauding Ferrum Capital’s investors. I did not knowingly agree to join any scheme to defraud anyone …”

Blackwell blasted that position, quoting Willy’s own words in court during her guilty plea hearing.

“I took money. I was a crook. I’m very sorry,” Willy said.

“[Willy] answered ‘Yes, your honor’ when asked whether she knew, ‘when you were doing these things, that you were stealing people’s money,’” Blackwell wrote – recalling what was said during the March guilty plea hearing.

“Willy admitted in the plea agreement to conspiring to defraud investors using Ferrum IV,” Blackwell wrote.

“She conspired with Allen and Cox to defraud investors by telling those investors that their money was being invested and was secure … when in truth and fact, she knew this to be false,” Blackwell wrote.

In at least one instance, prosecutors previously claimed people’s money did not go to Ferrum or Ferrum IV. Willy simply kept it for herself, case records claimed.

“There is not a separate conspiracy for fraud involving Ferrum Capital and another for fraud involving Ferrum IV,” Blackwell wrote.

Willy’s lawyer, Roy Barrera, Jr., said in open court in March, “She’s not responsible for the 60 million.”

Blackwell agreed – writing, “Willy is not responsible for the entire $60 million loss of the scheme, as Mr. Barrera correctly noted at the hearing, but only the losses of investors with whom the defendant was directly involved.”

Blackwell pointed out she can tell the court she thinks $18.56 million is too high and then the judge can decide before sentencing her whose dollar estimate is more accurate.

“By design, the plea agreement left the amount of loss attributable to Willy for the court to decide at sentencing. What Willy did admit – and, even in her motion to withdraw, still admits – is that she conspired with Cox and Allen to commit wire fraud,” Blackwell wrote.

None of that is sufficient reason to withdraw a guilty plea, Blackwell contended.

Willy filed her motion a few weeks after the government loss estimate – “231 days after she pleaded guilty,” as prosecutors point out.

Putting Barrera’s advice on trial

Willy fired Barrera recently and replaced him with Nashville attorney Paige Nutini.

Nutini questioned Barrera’s handling of the case as giving Willy little time to decide. Nutini painted a picture of Willy not getting to fully understand what the plea deal held her responsible for.

Blackwell disagreed, writing about meeting in January with Willy, her husband, Barrera and Rebecca Jones, an IRS special agent, to discuss the plea agreement.

“During this lengthy meeting, counsel for the United States discussed the evidence and answered extensive questions from Willy and her husband about the plea agreement, information and the legal process generally,” Blackwell wrote.

The plea agreement was emailed to Barrera five days in advance, Blackwell wrote.

A footnote in Blackwell’s writing stated, “The email also included the plea agreement of Paula Vacek, who admitted in that agreement to assisting Willy in committing fraud. Vacek later testified at the trial of Allen and Cox, including about her efforts to help launder fraud proceeds for, and at the direction of, Willy.”

Willy had between January 27 and a deadline of February 17 to decide.

“Willy had ample time and opportunity to consider the plea agreement and her ultimate decision,” Blackwell wrote.

Willy claimed she raised her concerns with Barrera about being held responsible for more than just her own conduct during the March guilty plea hearing.

She claimed she wrote him a note during the court hearing and he wrote back – telling her to be remorseful and take responsibility.

Blackwell wrote of that exchange, “His note during the hearing urging her to ‘Be remorseful’ and ‘Take responsibility,’ is not misadvice; it is the advice a defendant pleading guilty receives.”

Blackwell tried to get the other side of the story by seeing if Willy released Barrera from her attorney-client privilege.

Barrera wrote back to Blackwell, “I have not been released by Ms. Willy to discuss this matter. The attorney-client privilege remains.”

Another trial – not fair to victims

Blackwell wrote, “Willy would have been tried alongside Cox and Allen had she not pleaded guilty nearly five months before trial. Instead, she waited until months after that trial to move to withdraw her plea. A new trial would require the United States to duplicate that effort.”

During the Allen-Cox trial, Blackwell and his team called more than 30 witnesses.

“The victims in that case are also elderly. The United States would have to spend significant time and resources preparing for a second trial in that case as well,” Blackwell wrote.

Some of the Ferrum victims are from Lubbock and would need to travel to San Antonio.

“The victims, who have a statutory right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay … would see restitution deferred indefinitely,” Blackwell wrote.

Although Willy is not a licensed, practicing attorney, she does have a law degree, he wrote.

“She is a law school graduate who took ethics courses. She signed a plea agreement reciting that counsel had explained the elements of each offense and admitted that she acted knowing her representations to investors were false,” Blackwell wrote.

“Further, as the charges and trial evidence demonstrate, Willy is willing to lie to achieve her ends. During the federal investigation, she presented a false document with her clients’ forged signatures in order to stymie the investigation,” Blackwell wrote.

Willy lied to her victims and lied to federal agents, Blackwell claimed.

If she were allowed to take back her guilty plea “… for all her victims, the nightmare would continue,” Blackwell wrote.

He concluded with, “The motion should be denied.”